Pages Navigation Menu

Spirits • Fine Wine • Beer

Fine Cigars

Located inside our Wine Shoppe, Guess Who?®Cigar Shop is well stocked with a wide assortment of fine cigars for your smoking pleasure. Whatever the occasion, a bachelor party, a promotion at work, or just a day on the golf course, Guess Who?® is sure to have the cigar for you.

Our climate controlled humidor is filled with the finest and best known names in the cigar industry*, including Arturo Fuente, Romeo y Julieta, and Macanudo. Guess Who?® also carries many smaller brands and rising stars, including Man O War, Victor Sinclair and Carlos Torano. We are constantly bringing in new, exciting cigars as they become available.

Stop by Guess Who?® Cigar Shop the next time you’re in need of a fine smoke. Our friendly and knowledgeable staff will be happy to assist you.

These quality, handmade, premium honey flavored tip cigars, famous for their luscious sugar dipped flavored cigars, feature a mild, aromatic flavor and 100% long filler. The filler and binder are grown by Cojimar in the fertile Dominican Republic from authentic prized Piloto Cubano seed.


Guess Who does right to you with these bonus packs — perfect for sitting back on the fouth or a foursome of golf.

1.) Honduran Heritage Toro Assortment = Gispert, H UpmannLegacy, Romeo y Julieta 1875 Reserve, and Saint Luis Rey.
2.) Romeo y Julieta Toro Assortment = Rome y Julieta 1875, Romeo y Julieta Reserva Real, Romeo y Julieta Medallas de Oro Vintage, and Romeo by Romeo y Julieta.
3.) Dominican Heritage Toro Assortment = H Upmann 1844 Reserve, Montecristo White, Romeo y Julieta Reserva Real, and Vega Fina.


With its rich history and reputation, Montecristo has become one of the most popular cigars in the world and the standard by which all other cigars are judged. Meticulously hand-crafted at the Tabacalera de Garcia factory in the Dominican Republic, Montecristo cigars are available in a variety of premium blends for all different tastes.



Tatiana is a premium, hand-rolled flavored cigar made in the Dominican Republic with Cuban seed Dominican longfillers and Indonesian grown wrappers. All of the tobacco is aged for 2 years assuring you get a smooth mellow smoke. Tatiana cigars are packaged in a variety of box, tins, bundles, and tubos in the most popular and exotic flavors. If you want to enjoy one of the best-made and most affordable flavored cigars on the market, ‘flavor the moment’ with Tatiana.


Casa de Garcia is a versatile Dominican blend available in four different wrappers for a complete, medium-bodied treat.

Casa de Garcia is a fantastic everyday indulgence from cigar giant Altadis. Produced in the Dominican, the blends are a steal at these price points. Now, we’re not going to lead you on here, these blends won’t win any awards or ’90’ ratings. You can, however, expect solid blends that are perfect for enjoying while you cut your grass, drive to work, or even just relaxing at the end of a hard day. They’re cheap, efficient, and delicious.

Connecticut, Maduro, Nicaraguan and Sumatra; Casa de Garcia has something for everyone. The Connecticut-wrapped blend is light and creamy with an aromatic smoke. The maduro blend will be rich and chocolaty with a long finish. If you’re looking for something heartier, the Nicaraguan option will suit your needs with lots of earth and pepper nuances, while rounding out the bunch, the Sumatra-wrapped blend will be spicy and cedary with the spice lingering slightly on your palate.


Tabacalera Perdomo is a company built on three distinct pillars: quality, tradition and excellence. With an unparalleled attention to detail and a commitment to greatness that’s been handed down generation to generation. Perdomo makes more than the finest, premium hand rolled cigars in the world- They’ve created an ongoing legacy of distinction. Quality, Tradition. Excellence. Generation to generation.


The Nestor Miranda Special Selection Danno 2012 was the fifth release in the series from Miami Cigar, which commemorated the 20th anniversary of Miami Cigar Company. The Danno is cloaked in a dark San Andres maduro wrapper and medium in body and strength. This is a limited edition with a very limited number of boxes that was made, and somehow, we got one!

Don’t wait! Come in and buy, because we don’t have a ton and no one else does either.

*After much research and consultation with cigar experts,  Guess Who? does not carry acid cigars in the humidor.  Here are a couple of informative websites for more information: as well as